اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Review: Israeli dissidents 'bear witness' to the occupation
Published Monday 30/07/2012 (updated) 20/08/2012 16:21
Mati Milstein surrounded by a tear gas cloud in Bilin on Dec. 31, 2010.
(MaanImages/Fadi Arouri, HO)

Israeli Dissidents: Notes from a Slippery Slope, edited by Rechavia Berman

At the conclusion of an article describing her harrowing experience at an anti-occupation demonstration in the West Bank, Israeli journalist Lisa Goldman returns to her comfortable lifestyle in Tel Aviv.

After Goldman tells her friends about the Israeli army's violence -- tear gas, random arrests, the usual stuff -- they ask her why she keeps going to these demonstrations.

Goldman pauses for a moment before responding. "I guess I go to bear witness," she says.

"Bearing witness" seems to be the theme of Israeli Dissidents: Notes from a Slippery Slope, a compilation of 34 blog posts by ten leftist Israeli authors in which Goldman's article appears. The purpose of this endeavor, editor Rechavia Berman writes in the forward, is for "ardent supporters of Israel around the world [to] realize that in the name of unquestioning support, they are backing a policy that can only end in disaster."

That policy, of course, is the 45-year-old military occupation, and what Berman calls Israel's "slippery slope" towards fascism. The bloggers "bear witness" to the occupation’s atrocities in the West Bank -- though naturally there is very little about Gaza -- unapologetically skewering their own country's policies with moral clarity and discomfiting honesty.

In the age of the Internet and self-publishing, Berman's book -- comprised entirely of free and available content from the Web -- seems unnecessary. Though readers unfamiliar with the conflict will find some of the articles shocking, the point of the book is not to offer new content.

Rather, Berman aims to "present a document over the past years, of the gradual, accelerating process in which Israel’s political system is drifting even farther away from core principles and guaranteed rights inherent in the democratic concept." The so-called "only democracy in the Middle East" is fast becoming anything but, and the writers in Berman’s book are sounding the alarm bells.

With this mission in mind, many Palestinian readers, and those already familiar with the situation in the West Bank or Gaza, will yawn at some of the chapters. After all, anyone who has inhaled tear gas at a demonstration in Nabi Saleh, or witnessed a home demolition in the Jordan Valley has no need for personal Israeli narratives of the situation.

But the book still offers plenty for more keyed-in readers. While some of the selections have the snark and pithiness that one might expect from the blog format, many of the articles are well-researched, magazine-length pieces of hard-hitting journalism -- usually providing far more detail than the mainstream media.

Idan Landau's article on the troubling relationship between the US military industrial complex and aid to Israel is a must-read for anyone interested in the international dynamics that fund the violence here. Landau's articles on Israeli policies in East Jerusalem's Silwan and the Jordan Valley are illuminating and incisive condemnations of the occupation's bureaucracy that will surely leave its apologists speechless.

For those more curious about internal Jewish debates, there are two articles by Noam Rotem offering chilling and detailed historical comparisons between Nazi Germany and current Israeli policies. Shalom Bogulavsky’s post reimagining the Jewish minority in Odessa as anything other than helpless victims is also instructive in proposing new Jewish narratives.

Some of the posts leave Israel's occupation almost completely aside, focusing instead on Israeli domestic politics. Hila Benyovitz Hoffman's satires of the treatment of women in increasingly theocratic Israel, and Yossi Gurvitz's article on the rise of the religious-nationalist "Jewish Brotherhood" describe a breakdown of democracy within Israel itself. The "slippery slope" away from democratic ideals is occurring within Israeli Jewish society as well.

But Israel's occupation is never too far away -- and as the book shifts between women’s rights in Jerusalem and water rights in the Jordan Valley, it becomes clear that the forms of oppression one finds within Israel are connected to the much more obvious and legal oppression on the other side of the Green Line. The Israeli Right has taken over the entirety of this land, steadily establishing its rule not only in settlements throughout the West Bank but within Israel as well.

The Right’s ideology hovers over Israel like a dark cloud. A storm is coming, and the bloggers in Berman's compilation have read the weather report. It's time for Israel's supporters to take cover.


Israeli Dissidents: Notes from a Slippery Slope is available as an e-book on Amazon.

Print Send to friend
1 ) Rechavia Berman / Israel
31/07/2012 03:14
Thanks for the kind review. I'm here if anyone wants to ask anything. Thank you for taking an interest.

2 ) Julie / USA
31/07/2012 07:05
"...there are two articles by Noam Rotem offering chilling and detailed historical comparisons between Nazi Germany and current Israeli policies." ...funny thing is, we don't even need to read those two articles to see how obviously alike izrahell is to its nazi kin. but it's nice to know it's also being documented for those who want to try to deny it !!!!!!!!!!!!

3 ) Witness / Results
31/07/2012 18:02
"Bearing witness to THE OCCUPATION" will no more end it, than
bearing witness to the resistance, and both WILL CONTINUE,
UNTIL THE TWO SIDES REACH A NEGOTIATED PEACE AGREEMENT.

4 ) Rami / Jerusalem, Israel
31/07/2012 20:53
Misguided (and well paid for their blog) as these dissidents are, they are a testimony to Israel's democracy. If Arab dissidents under the rule of the PA or Hamas tried to express opposition to their rulers, they would be shot or hung after a quick military "trial". Vive La Difference!!!

5 ) Rechavia Berman / Israel
31/07/2012 20:58
Alas, we do not make policy in our country... Or that would have long since happened.

6 ) @ Julie-2 / USA too
31/07/2012 21:10
Your "comparisons between Nazi Germany and Israeli policies"
are rediculous, since
1- NAZI GERMANY POLICIES had both the intent and the success
in genocide, and MURDERING MILLIONS, while
2- ISRAELI POLICIES had both the intent of Two-States for Two-Peoples,
and the success in collaborating with UNRWA in providing humanitarian aid !!
- If a Nazi-like genocide was Israel's intent, then why does it still
PROVIDE GAZA & THE WEST BANK WITH ELECTRICITY & WATER ??

7 ) asad / Australia
01/08/2012 02:14
Israel provide Gaza and West bank with water they steal from Palestinian areas and Palestinians pay for the water and electricity. The UNRWA is a colonial institution to reduce the worlds realisation of the Israeli crimes since 1948

8 ) colin wrong / usa
01/08/2012 02:31
yawn, tell us new story we heard how bad (wink wink) israel is. what's new?

9 ) Rechavia Berman / Israel
01/08/2012 02:55
"ISRAELI POLICIES had both the intent of Two-States for Two-Peoples, and the success in collaborating with UNRWA in providing humanitarian aid !! - If a Nazi-like genocide was Israel's intent, then why does it still PROVIDE GAZA & THE WEST BANK WITH ELECTRICITY & WATER ??" No need to shout. Indeed, Israel's crimes are far short than holocaust. However, a detailed and sustained comparison can be made with Nazi occupation of Western Europe and Non-Jews. As for Gaza - separate reply

10 ) Rechavia Berman / Israel
01/08/2012 02:57
As for Gaza - Israel self-admittedly calibrates its provision towards the Gaza Strip for the lowest minimum that won't result in a mass humanitarian crisis. Right on the edge. This is Israeli official statements. The step right above "mass humanitarian crisis" is not "hunky dory", to say the least.

11 ) Rechavia Berman / Israel
01/08/2012 02:58
"Misguided (and well paid for their blog)" Excuse me? Care to elaborate?

12 ) Colin Wright / usa
01/08/2012 19:00
ok #11 not misguided but an idiot on payroll

13 ) @ Rechavia (#s 9 & 10) / ONLY PEACE
02/08/2012 15:49
Where it is true that Israel is NOT a Perfect State,
Nazism and Zionism are far more different than you suggest,
which is perhaps best shown by their slogans:
- Nazi slogans over entrances to several concentration camps
read “ARBEIT MACHT FREI,” or “Work Makes Free”,
(The world knows now NAZIS GAVE THEM ONLY DEATH.), and
- a Zionist equivalent today would be “Negotiations Makes Statehood”,
and the world knows ZIONISTS WOULD GIVE THEM ONLY PEACE.


14 ) Rechavia Berman / Israel
03/08/2012 11:38
"and - a Zionist equivalent today would be “Negotiations Makes Statehood”, and the world knows ZIONISTS WOULD GIVE THEM ONLY PEACE. " Israel does NOT want peace OR a two state solution. At least not the current government. No government in Israel in 16 years can be argued to have pursued *peace* seriously. Israel is pretending to want negotiations in return for time to create facts on the ground.

15 ) Rechavia Berman / Israel
03/08/2012 11:40
On whose payroll though? That's what I don't get. Introduce me to my alleged employer, please.

16 ) ABE / USA
12/08/2012 02:48
Encourage these "israeli dissidents" to move into Ram'allah, or Jenin, or better yet, into Gaza!! See what happens. If they don't leap at your offer, then they're hypocrites.
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

President Abbas phones Palestinian Arab Idol finalist
War photographers share insight in new work
Israel rabbi speaks out on being gay and Orthodox

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013