اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

The ABCs of Israeli demolitions in the West Bank
Published Thursday 16/08/2012 (updated) 17/08/2012 17:38
A cat walks behind Palestinian children in al-Mufaqara, near Hebron on
Aug. 8. (Reuters/Mohamad Torokman)
RAMALLAH (IRIN) -- Rasmiyye Hamande has lived in a cave in the West Bank for most of her life, which may have been a blessing in disguise. "This cave," she says, "can't be demolished so easily."

Other places in the village of Al-Mufaqara, in Area C -- the 60 percent of the West Bank under Israeli military control -- are more easily destroyed.

Some 622 structures were demolished by Israeli forces in the West Bank in 2011, a 42 percent increase from 2010. The figures for 2012 could well surpass last year's numbers, as by the end of July, some 395 demolished structures in the West Bank were registered by the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.

Al-Mufaqara is one of 12 villages in an area recently declared "firing zone 918" by Israel. The Israeli Ministry of Defense wants to demolish eight of these villages and evacuate their residents to make way for a military training. About 1,500 Palestinians are expected to be forcibly displaced if this demolition is carried out.

The army says the training exercises in firing zone 918 are necessary to deal with shortcomings exposed during the 2006 Israel-Lebanon conflict, and the Ministry of Defense has indicated that the villagers will still be allowed to use the land on weekends and Jewish holidays.

Firing zones like this one, all officially intended for military training, make up about 18 percent of the West Bank; 45 percent of all demolitions in the Israeli-controlled Area C of the West Bank since 2010 have taken place in firing zones.

IRIN takes a look at the circumstances surrounding these demolition orders.

When and why are Palestinian structures in Area C considered illegal by Israel?

All structures need government-approved permits; those without can be demolished. But acquiring a permit from the Israeli Civil Administration - a military body tasked with overseeing occupied Palestinian territory -- for Palestinian construction in Area C is close to impossible.

According to OCHA, the Civil Administration rejected 94 percent of Palestinians' building permit applications in Area C between 2000 and 2007. In 2010, only four out of 444 building permit applications in Area C were approved. The Civil Administration told IRIN that there is no set time period for the review of requested building permits, and that every applications is examined differently.

In villages outside firing zones, the main problem is restrictive Israeli planning. Requested building permits must fit into spatial plans that have not changed since they were drawn up in the 1930s, when the area was under British administration.

Inside closed military zones, access is prohibited without a special permit, unless one is a permanent resident. Permits for construction are only available if the Israeli commander in charge issues a special order.

Structures are also prohibited on land considered by Israel to be archeological sites. This is the case in Susiya, in the south Hebron hills; 70 percent of the existing structures in the community have pending demolition orders.

All told, 70 percent of Area C is off-limits for Palestinian construction and another 29 percent is heavily restricted.

Demolition orders can target solid houses, tents or other structures including school, water wells, solar panels, electricity grids and animal shelters. Out of the 622 structures destroyed by Israeli forces, 222 were homes, 170 were animal shelters, two were classrooms and two were mosques.

What can affected communities do against demolition orders?

The Civil Administration first issues a so-called "stop-work order" to the owner of the structure. In the order, the date and place of the hearing and the relevant sub-committee of the Civil Administration is noted. Those affected may raise their objections to the order during the sub-committee hearing, with the theoretical option to acquire a permit retroactively.

After the hearing, the Civil Administration usually issues a final demolition order, against which a new petition is possible. If the court rules in favor of the affected communities, or suggests modifications, the demolition is suspended. Once the court legally backs the demolition, it can be executed.

Guy Inbar, spokesman for the Civil Administration, told IRIN that in the cases of the Susiya community and firing zone 918, the court suspended the demolition orders. But it also found that the Palestinian buildings in these areas were illegal, citing a previous court ruling that had prohibited any construction in those areas.

Are the demolitions legal under international law?

Article 53 of the Fourth Geneva Convention states that "any destruction by the Occupying Power of real or personal property belonging individually or collectively to private persons, or to the State, or to other public authorities, or to social or cooperative organizations, is prohibited, except where such destruction is rendered absolutely necessary by military operations."

Article 46 of the Hague Convention states that "the lives of persons, and private property, as well as religious convictions and practice, must be respected."

The Israeli government holds the view that the West Bank is not under occupation, but has the status of "disputed territory", which limits the applicability of the provisions of International Humanitarian Law.

What responsibility does Israel have towards Palestinians living in structures set to be demolished?

Ramesh Rajasingham, local head of OCHA, said that Israel as an "occupying power has an obligation to protect Palestinian civilians and to administer the territory in a manner that ensures their welfare and basic needs. The ongoing destruction of civilian homes does not meet that obligation."

In the case of the Palestinian village of Zanuta, which is built on an Israeli archeological site, the court asked the state to provide alternatives for those living in homes set to be demolished.

According to a report in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, "The state representative responded saying that it was not the responsibility of the military authority to find a solution."

What happens after a demolition is carried out?

Humanitarian organizations like OCHA often provide emergency shelters for Palestinians whose homes have been destroyed. But even these emergency shelters, if built without permits in Area C, may be considered illegal by the Israeli Civil Administration.

In many cases, such as in firing zone 918, Palestinians reconstruct their homes after demolition. Others might live with family members until finding a new home. A minority among them also have second homes in Areas A or B, the 40 percent of the West Bank under full or partial administration of the Palestinian Authority.

For the residents of the eight villages still designated for demolition in firing zone 918, expulsion is still hard to imagine.

Khalid Jabareen, from one of the villages, told IRIN: "We see in the media how the world lives, how Israelis live. Compared to this, I can say that we don't live."
Print Send to friend
1 ) Dio / USA
17/08/2012 00:17
What the author fails to mention is the fact that Israeli settlers in the same "military areas" or "firing zones" don't seem to have any trouble obtaining permits and are almost never demolished. The author also fails to mention the common-place situation in which Palestinians are forcibly removed and their structures demolished in said "closed military areas", and then once the cleansing has been done, Israeli settlers are given permits to build on the same land stolen from the Palestinians.

2 ) Bill / USA
29/08/2012 18:52
To Whom it may concern: The term "area C" leads everyone to think it is
a particular area when in fact it is all the open area between towns, villages, and cities in the west bank. So long as Israel holds the lands deemed "AreaC' there will and cannot be two states> Somebody needs to publish a map and show the world just what areas A,B,and C, are.

3 ) Jewel / Netherlands
09/09/2012 16:38
To Bill/USA
As far as I know those maps exists. And you can find them freely on the internet. But who cares? The world still feels its own pains as the most important. And if I was a Palestine I would have lost all hopes in between: 65 years of suffering is a mens life!

4 ) Rami / Palestine
26/09/2012 08:14
It's often forgotten, or rather neglected, that most of these villages existed BEFORE the term "Area C" existed.

5 ) Jeanine / UK
05/12/2012 20:35
To Bill/USA & interested others: You can find many maps of the Occupied West Bank at palmaps.org and there are some here as well, though they are older, they still show the "Judaisation" settlements, walls and roads here: http://thealmondtreebook.com/about/history/

6 ) JoeFattal / USA
06/01/2013 21:00
Very simple and it doesn't take a high school graduate to get to the point. Unless the Palestinians has the means to confront the Israelis militarily, Israel will continue its settlements. They know they have the upperhand and they know when they are faced with a weak opponent. And to add to it the US is backing Israel and God only knows only knows why. Unless something drastic happens to that part of the world the situation on the ground will remain the same. Deal with it.

7 ) Johnny benson / USA
26/04/2013 19:45
Truly,a ....thorny issue.....one must feel for the poor famlliys.....I believe Israel needs to show some compassion.....fair is fair
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Full text: Erekat complaint to Canadian foreign minister
Full text: Youth groups condemn national division, urge PLO vote
Full text: Statement from Global Palestinian Right to Return Coalition

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013