اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

10 years on from Nativity Church siege, deportees 'forgotten'
Published Thursday 10/05/2012 (updated) 11/05/2012 14:15

BETHLEHEM (Ma'an) -- Ten years after Israel exiled 39 Palestinians taking refuge in Bethlehem's Nativity Church, deportees say they have been forgotten by Palestinian leaders.

On May 10, 2002, Israeli forces ended a 39-day siege on the church after striking a deal with Palestinian leaders to send 39 people given sanctuary in the church to Gaza and Europe.

When Israeli tanks surrounded Bethlehem on April 2, 2002, around 220 locals -- including around 40 priests and nuns -- took shelter in the church. Over the next 39 days, eight Palestinians were killed inside the church and 27 others injured.

The siege on the site believed to be Jesus' birthplace sparked outrage in the Vatican as monks sheltering inside pleaded for international assistance.

Former Bethlehem Governor Salah Tamari headed the negotiations team to end the siege, and told Ma'an TV the deportation deal was reached without his knowledge.

He recalled his shock when Israeli officials told him Palestinians would be exiled, and said he called the office of President Yasser Arafat to resign as chief negotiator.

Israeli officials had demanded a list of names of everyone in the church, Tamari said.

"Since the first moment, we refused to give any names. We told [the Israelis] if you have anyone who's wanted, give us their names and we'll see if their charges affect the Palestinian law, we'll hold them accountable."

Rafat Obayyat was one of 27 Palestinians injured by Israeli attacks on the church. He is in a wheelchair due to his injuries.

He told Ma'an the grotto was the safest place in the church during the siege. Food was scarce and small amounts of pasta would be rationed between everyone, he added.



After a decade in exile, deportees say they have been abandoned by the Palestinian Authority and all political factions. They have not been allowed to return to their families in the West Bank.

Deportees had planned to demonstrate on Thursday but canceled the protest to stand beside prisoners on hunger strike, spokesman for the group Fahmi Kanan said at a press conference on Monday.

Instead, deportees will go on a 3-day hunger strike on Thursday in solidarity with detainees in Israeli jails, Kanan said.

'A dangerous precedent'

Former detainee and researcher Abdul Nasser Farwaneh said the deportation deal was a clear violation of international law and human rights.

The Palestinian leadership's acceptance of the deal to send Palestinians into exile set a dangerous precedent and over the last decade Israel has deported hundreds more Palestinians, Farwaneh said in a statement.

He urged the international community to send a commission of inquiry into Israel's siege on one of the world's holiest sites.

He also called for greater efforts to bring the deportees home and said the ongoing failure to bring them back from exile reflected Palestinian indifference to the issue.
Print Send to friend
1 ) Simple / Truth
10/05/2012 01:31
With the Oslo Accords dead, Israel should exile the 100s of PLO, that were allowed to return in exchange for their promise of negotiated settlement, and they too will be forgotten after 10 years, by the remaining Palestinians leaders, and the whole world too.

2 ) Shirlee / Australia
10/05/2012 02:09
Unusual for 'Palestinians' to forget their terrorists. They usually glorify them by namely places and things after them. The people were terrorists. It's lucky for them they were only deported. What cowards though to hide in a church. Really shows there mentality the fact that 40 explosive devices were left in the church by them, several being booby-trapped.

3 ) Malone / Hfx
10/05/2012 02:20
Professional whiners...what surprised me at the time was that anyone was willing to take these misfits into their country...must have been well paid out of the PA coffers.

4 ) oh please / where i am wanted
10/05/2012 03:40
pnly you jews move in univited and then and then move out as many neighbors as possible.....the nazi had very willing students in the jews

5 ) Arnold / Canada
10/05/2012 14:20
Why did the Palestinians take over the church instead of a mosque. Because they were hoping the church would be attacked and destroyed thereby getting the christian world to be against Israel.

6 ) @ #4 / USA
10/05/2012 20:17
Go to any Muslim state that exists, where you are wanted*, rather than:
- remain as terrorists where you are NOT, and continue
- trying to build another Muslim state on top the only Jewish State !!

* Iraq and Syria needs rebuilding right now.

7 ) Joe Kelsall / UK
10/05/2012 21:00
The Palestinian christians are there, and elsewhere, to tell the tale of how Israel has strangled their businesses with their illegal settlements.Those in the know, in the christian world have much justification in being against Israel. Go take a look for yourself; you have nothing to fear from Palestinians. I'll take you, if you don't believe me!

8 ) Phil / UK
10/05/2012 23:00
7) Oh really? Next you will be telling us that Palestinian terrorists have never murdered none Israelis. I think that Italian relief worker who used to hang around in Gaza would disagree with you! And considering the fact that the PA goes about threatening Pal shopkeepers to keep them from selling Israeli goods, and Pal workers to stop them from working for Israelis. Your argument about Israeli villages strangling businesses doesn't accurately fit the reality of life on the ground old boy !

9 ) Shirlee / Australia
11/05/2012 01:23
Joe, out of interest where do you get your illegal settlements from ? There are a few outposts in the hills of Judea and Samaria.. no Christians live there, just Jewish and Arab farmers. The Arabs in areas where there are Christians, have intimidated them to such an extent that they are leaving. i suggest you do some accurate reading on the subject.

10 ) Shirlee / Australia
11/05/2012 01:27
By the way Joe, I was in Israel, including Judea and Samaria in March. True you have nothing to fear from Arabs in Israel, but see what happens in Judea and Samaria if you are Jewish, have an Israeli passport, or even have an Israeli stamp in you foreign passport..............By the way who/what are Palestinians? There is no such race of people.

11 ) Mahmoud El-Yousseph / Exiled Palestinian
11/05/2012 06:29
The real terrorist is the one who steals the land, kill women and children for sport. People who resist a brutal foreign military occupation are called heroes and freedom fighters. Places of worship and burial places are protected by Islam and Muslims. Even under the rules of war. But when it come to Israel, those bastards get away with murder every time. Israel act above the law that govern civilized nations. Israel break every agreement she is a party to. Never trust a liar!

12 ) Nancy / US/Germany
11/05/2012 08:49
The "Prince of Peace", a Jew and a sonof Abraham was born there 2000 years ago to bring Peace to ALL men and most of all, the sons of Abraham-- the children of Israel and the childen of Ishmael. He loves you very much! Get along and love one another! All things are possible with the God of Abraham who sent him.
Shalom, Salem Aleichem, Peace, Love and Prayers to you all!
In the Name of the Prince of Peace-- a gentile Christian.

13 ) southparkbear / usa
13/05/2012 07:09
we did not forget you. that is why you cannot come back. the issue here is that arabs and palestinians in particular forgot about those thugs

14 ) Gaymer Kharken / Malaysia
14/05/2012 17:30
That church was desecrated in every disgusting possible foul way.

15 ) Robert / US
14/05/2012 18:21
To shirlee look up ringworm children ,and what chaim Sheba did against darker skinned Jews. And to think they named a hospital after this madman. GO AHEAD LOOK IT UP !!!. YOU TERRORIST SUPPORTER..

16 ) Rami / Palestine
17/05/2012 11:18
#2 - which ones are the terrorists? Those who shot and killed 39 people hiding in one of Christianity's holiest sites...or 40 people including unarmed civilians, priests, nuns and monks who hid in one of Christianity's holiest sites, a church which is supposed to be a respected sanctuary of safety, due to tanks, snipers and soldiers surrounding said church and threatening to murder them all? The silence of Jewish aggression against Christianity and Islam is deafening as well.
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Hospital under investigation after woman's death
KFC comes to Gaza ... by tunnel
Vatican under scrutiny as nuns, landowners lose Israel wall challenge

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013