اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Lessons from Gaza
Published Thursday 28/06/2012 (updated) 10/07/2012 21:17
A Palestinian boy stands in front of a gate leading to the Erez
crossing between Israel and Gaza during a protest calling for
an end to Israel`s blockade. (MaanImages/Hatem Omar, File)

This month, I mark two important events which took place five years ago and changed the course of my life. It has been five years since I moved to Israel from New York and five years since Hamas took over the Gaza Strip and the closure of the enclave tightened.

I was job hunting from the Haifa bedroom my mother and aunt shared growing up, reading in Haaretz about Gaza's factories shutting down, and here I am, five years later, working for Gisha, an Israeli human rights organization promoting freedom of movement for Gaza residents.

When I moved to Israel, hoping to live nearer to my dear grandmothers and make use of my newly obtained international affairs degree, I didn't expect to find myself where I am today. I remember asking, in my second interview for the job -- so why Gaza? And why freedom of movement?

For a starry-eyed American-Israeli girl, Gaza seemed sticky, far away and obscure. I had never been there, and my only association was my mother's stories of driving with friends to eat fish on the beach at a time before my existence was imaginable to her.

Reading about what was happening in Gaza in June and July of 2007 and thinking of the memories she had shared with me, I had to know: how did we get from there to where we are now?

A few weeks after I started working at Gisha, Israel's security cabinet made a decision to limit freedom of movement into and out of the Strip, making official a policy which had already been in effect since that June and rendering Gisha its most vocal opponent in Israel.

In those early days, like most people who know little about Gaza, I had a hard time understanding how the enclave figured into the larger picture of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Still, I connected, deeply and immediately, with the stories of the individuals my organization represented in proceedings before Israeli administrative authorities and courts.

Many of them were young people like me -- young professionals, business owners and civil servants. Hearing their stories and speaking to them was like being at the edge of another world and finding that the people on the other side aren't unlike you. It was exhilarating and heart-breaking and motivating.

They were students, as I had been, who wanted to study abroad, as I had done. They were engineers, like my father, who were struggling to cope with dilapidated infrastructure. They were young mothers who wanted to advance their careers to better support their children. Freedom of movement was an essential pre-condition for these individuals to fulfill their goals.

Gaza was more than just what you could read in the paper or see on the news. It didn't make the question of Israel's security any less urgent, but it did make me appreciate that in meeting its security needs, one had to also consider the fate of Gaza's 1.6 million residents.

Five years later, no one is closer to figuring out next steps in the difficult political landscape of this region, especially regarding Gaza. That notwithstanding, individuals like myself and like the people served by my organization are marking other, more mundane anniversaries: they are trying to advance their careers and plan families; waking up and doing the wash; preparing breakfast and visiting friends.

It's not because I am starry-eyed that I work to promote human rights, but rather because I am a realist. Anyone looking closely enough will see that if we are no closer to solving the conflict than we were 64 years ago or to figuring out what to do about Gaza than we were five years ago, the everyday needs and rights of average residents should figure even more prominently, not less.

This is what Gaza has to teach us about this conflict. If we care about the future, then individuals, especially young people, should have access to the tools to build better lives for themselves and their families. They should be able to strive for the best attainable standard of living, irrespective of who their visionless leaders are and as long as their striving for a better life doesn’t infringe on the security and rights of others.

In fact, in the last two years, Israel has relaxed some of the travel restrictions to and from Gaza without compromising its security, and much, much more can be done. My hope for this solemn anniversary is that those who are newly engaging the issue of Gaza, as I did five years ago, will learn quickly that security and human rights are anything but mutually exclusive.

The author is director of international relations at Gisha - Legal Center for Freedom of Movement.
Print Send to friend
1 ) Mark of Lewiston / USA
29/06/2012 08:13
Well said. The policy is wrong and fixed in stone on both sides of the border. Neither side gets security if it denies security to the other side.

2 ) Julie / USA
29/06/2012 14:43
wow, what a bunch of pseudo-intellectual crap to make the situation in Gaza appear so complex. "no one is closer to figuring out next steps in the difficult political landscape of this region"...this attitude is pure BULLSHIT !! there IS a very simple solution: 1) ENFORCE UN RESOLUTIONS and HUMANITARIAN & INTERNATIONAL LAW ON IZRAEL. 2) HOLD IZRAEL TO ACCOUNT FOR CRIMES - SANCTION/CUT AID/PROSECUTE IZRAEL for non-compliance with INTERNATIONAL & UNIVERSAL HUMANITARIAN LAWS.

3 ) southparkbear / usa
29/06/2012 16:12
i am all that arab world helps gaza as much as i am for total separation from gaza no to or from for the next generation or two

4 ) No to propaganda / Yes to truth
29/06/2012 17:02
That is such an honest analysis, I am amazed this site actually published it. 2005, under international pressure to make trust building gestures, Israel attempted to disengage from Gaza. The 'wise prophets' of BS said it would lead to peace. It lead to a civil war between Hamas and Fatah and thousands of rocket attacks on Israel. But we need people like you to bind the wounds on both sides. You won't see peace because there is too much hate, and too many seeking to justify it. But keep binding.

5 ) Tibi / Tubas
29/06/2012 17:25
The Lessons from GAZA is that FIRING ROCKETS IS STUPID, since
it achieves nothing, rarely harms Israel, DEVASTATES GAZA, and
JUSTIFIES ISRAEL MAINTAINING THE BLOCKADE.

6 ) Major Uzi, ShaBaK / Israel
29/06/2012 18:49
Lousy job this girl got. Poor girl.... Gazans move to Egypt.

7 ) Matt / USA
29/06/2012 19:22
The PA Arabs have done nothing to promote their own well-being. They receive huge sums of money from many different sources and yet seem incapable or unwilling to focus on their own infrastructure and economic growth. The leaders of the Palestinian Arab people as well as the other Arab and Muslim leaders in the area are not helping them progress. Why should the onus lay on a people which the Arabs have repeatedly tried to kill, anhiliate and expel from their 3000 year old homeland?

8 ) Richard SM / UK
29/06/2012 20:25
It's not difficult to solve - all the big decisions have been taken by the UN Security Council: Israel must withdraw; the borders are already set; the Palestinians have the right to return. It just needs implementing.

9 ) Mary / U.S.
29/06/2012 20:53
And please add that the right of return issue for all of Palestine is an issue of human rights which is now an Israeli policy of racism. All People should have equal rights in Israel and there should be an independent state of Palestine.

10 ) southparkbear / usa
30/06/2012 07:07
mary, israelis are all for palestinians right to return to egypt, jordan....

11 ) Mel / Gaza
30/06/2012 10:00
One state with equal rights for all!

12 ) southparkbear / usa
30/06/2012 17:41
mary has some good points in particular palestinians right to return to gaza

13 ) Nathan Greenberg / Canada
30/06/2012 23:07
Matt, Israel is your homeland as much as Timbaktu is mine. But if you insist that it is, you better agree that Arabs who were expelled from it can go back because otherwise your claim doesn't make sense.

14 ) BDS / Canada
01/07/2012 12:07
All Palestinians dispossessed of their lands and properties by the Israeli, zionists have the right to have their lands and properties returned. And the brutal attacks on Gaza and imprisonment of Gazans must stop. Palestine will be free when there is justice and all rights and lands are restored.

15 ) Edithann / USA
01/07/2012 15:32
Julie # 2.."what a bunch of pseudo-intellectual crap to make the situation in Gaza appear so complex. "no one is closer to figuring out next steps in the difficult political landscape of this region"...this attitude is pure BULLSHIT !! there IS a very simple solution: 1) ENFORCE UN RESOLUTIONS and HUMANITARIAN & INTERNATIONAL LAW ON IZRAEL. 2) HOLD IZRAEL TO ACCOUNT FOR CRIMES - SANCTION/CUT AID/PROSECUTE IZRAEL for non-compliance with INTERNATIONAL & UNIVERSAL HUMANITARIAN LAWS"


TATA

16 ) shirley / australia
01/07/2012 16:18
israel should just get used to it pals are going to get a state and it is isrealis and their illegal occupation that will be doing the moving back over the border as for securityas long as Isreal continues ocxcupying other peoples land there will never be peace Isreal occupies 3 countries another peice of jewish self delusion as for Isreal lifting gaza seige pure garnage if you meen Isreal is not still trying to keep pals just above starvation levels some change EGYPT RELAXED TRAVEL NOT ISREAL

17 ) @ shirley-16 / USA
02/07/2012 20:52
The "Pals should just get used to it, that the state they are going to get",
will be determined by compromise, if NOT surrender, to Israeli terms,
and Israel is content to wait, under the existing conditions, NO matter long
it takes, for the "Pals to get used to either Compromising or Surrender !!!

18 ) @ Julie-2 / USA too
02/07/2012 21:02
Expecting UN resolutions or laws to change anything is more BULLSHIT,
even if they did NOT suuport Israel more than Palestinians,
and in all truth, the ONLY WAY the Gaza Situation will change
is for one of two things to happen:
1- Gaza will reach a negotiated peace agreement with Israel, or
2- Gaza will militarily defeat Israel, and
since both seem utterly impossible, the Gaza Situation will NOT change,
and probably neither will the West Bank Situation, for a very long time !!!

19 ) johnny benson / usa
03/07/2012 19:58
its all really simple...the arab leaders have lied to their perople....sold them a bill of faulty goods ....leaving them suffer while they are stealing the billions given to them by the idiot world.....

20 ) More lessons / Are Needed
06/07/2012 16:45
Gaza's government has NO international relationship with Israel. And in fact,
Gaza's government is committed to destroying Israel, so:
1- there is Neither a reason for Israel to issue any travel permits, f
rom Gaza into Israel, even for medical reasons,
2- Nor even to Cooperate with UNRWA aid deliveries,
3- Nor to supply Gaza with any water or electricity,
until Gaza's government creates a Non-Hostile relationship with Israel !!!
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Analysts: Mursi cuts Syria ties to woo West, boost image
Has the Obama-Kerry charm offensive failed?
Rowhani 'tone' may reopen doors for Iran

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013