اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Analysis: President Abbas, if you don't want to fight, negotiate
Published Wednesday 04/07/2012 (updated) 05/07/2012 14:39
(MaanImages/File)

I cannot work out an explanation for the state of "no peace, but no war" which has prevailed in Palestine in the last two years.

We Palestinians neither want to fight the Israeli occupation, nor to negotiate with them. We use the term "steadfastness" to describe this stalemate, as if doing nothing at all and remaining motionless has become steadfastness.

Palestinian intellectuals have long criticized the Arab regimes because they neither want to fight Israel, nor accept reconciliation with the occupying country.

For 40 years, we have been suffering fatally on a daily basis under occupation, while Arab TV stations have been slamming Israel in their news, and at the same time resistance fighters were being detained in Arab countries for politically-motivated security reasons.

At that point, late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat was fed up and broke the silence by saying that the same Palestinians who fight and carry out military operations will make peace and sign agreements.

Over the past two years, the Palestinian leadership -- including the PLO and Hamas -- have been facing a crisis over what slogan to raise.

Therefore, neither the Palestinian public knows what its leadership is up to, nor does the leadership know what the public wants.

Palestinian leaders restricted themselves to issuing sharply-worded political statements cursing and slamming occupation, and blaming this occupation for as many offenses as they wanted. In the newsroom, we receive statements from Palestinian leaders reading as bizarre sentences as: "So and so condemns the occupation for the murder of children in Rafah."

And it goes on. So and so Palestinian leader condemns the Israeli incursion in Nablus, and another leader holds the occupation responsible for the confiscation of one third of West Bank land. Another leader denounces Israeli attempts to judaize Jerusalem and to break into the al-Aqsa Mosque or carry out excavations under the mosque.

Some leaders even condemned other leaders because they did not condemn the Israel occupation over detaining someone. What good is this? Is this the policy we need in order to free Palestinian prisoners and liberate Jerusalem?

For two years, the Palestinian leadership has refused to negotiate with Israel. They went to the UN seeking recognition of a Palestinian state, but the US fought that bid very firmly, proving that it is the number one enemy when it comes to UN resolutions on the Palestinian people’s rights.

Up until now, the Palestinian leadership still refuses to negotiate with Netanyahu or meet with Israeli leaders, but at the same time they urge the Palestinians to halt resistance activities. So how will this dilemma end?

Seemingly, Israel will eventually take control of the whole West Bank, complete its plans to judaize the Jordan Valley, segregate Gaza once and for all, and the Arab city of Jerusalem will end up a poor neighborhood within the greater Jewish Jerusalem.

Jerusalem will eventually meet the same end as Jaffa, which was once the most important Palestinian city before it became nothing more than a poor neighborhood in Tel Aviv. Despite everything, the Palestinian leadership is still adamant in rejecting both negotiations and resistance.

President Abbas, if you don't want to fight, and you don't want us to fight, go and negotiate so we can see what could happen.

Nasser Laham is the editor-in-chief of Ma'an News Agency.
Print Send to friend
1 ) ABE / USA
04/07/2012 19:22
Well said. I could not agree more.

2 ) Emile / Palestine
04/07/2012 19:46
Mr. Laham: Fighting and negotiating are not the only options. Neither of these options are correct for the current situation. Unfortunately the PA, their families and friends are making too much money with the status quo. They may believe they are doing the bidding of the Palestinian people, but this is just rationalization of there impotent and complicit behavior. The PA needs to disband and we must begin peaceful civil disobedience demanding our rights in the one state, river to sea.

3 ) Giacomo / USA
04/07/2012 21:15
Mr. Laham - The US just like the Russians, Chinese, Arabs, and every other voting block in the UN use their power to further their political/financial interests - singling out the US, though an easy target, is not balanced and does not further the Palestinian cause. The only action that will further the Palestinian cause and bring peace to the region, is a unified Palestinian government, with a mandate from the Palestinian people, not the UN as surrogate, and then negotiations w/the Israelis.

4 ) ronen / israel
04/07/2012 21:57
this is a good advice. bibi is the most centrist in his entire camp. the stronger the israeli leader is the better for you. bibi is strong and rightwing and wants peace. these characteristics are not gonna be around for long

5 ) tora3x / Japan
04/07/2012 22:17
Agreed. I'm really disappointed at the cancellation of Abbas-Mofaz meeting.?To be exact, disappointed at both side's obstacles for "progress". I believe personal relationship is vital for breakthrough in any phase. Even more so for the tie of top management. It's valuable & unreplaceable. At this time the meeting should not be expected more than relationship building. It seems it's the time top management decision is needed for right move, even though there are disputes domestically. Ma'assalama

6 ) Yehuda Solomon / Israel
05/07/2012 00:13
A very good and well-presented essay. Excellent points all around. What else can anyone say ??? ... @ 3) Giacomo/USA, No ... Nasser Laham speaks the TRUTH about the USA ... Besides us, it IS the USA who is basically the sole blocker of a (second) Palestinian nation ... NOT the Russians, Chinese, Arabs, Europeans or anyone else. It IS the USA who on the 1 hand says it supports a 2-nation solution and condemns our settlement policy but on the other hand kills all attempts to (cont.)

7 ) Yehuda Solomon / Israel
05/07/2012 00:24
support the Palestinians at the U.N. or internationally. Hell, the USA even stopped aid to the Palestinians for a while when they were simply admitted to UNESCO, not the full U.N. SO HOW DAMN HYPOCRITICAL CAN YOU GET ??? For the purpose of recognizing a (second) Palestinian nation, it really doesn't even matter any more if the Palestinians get "united" or not. The USA could very logically and easily just focus on W. Bank Palestinian nationhood and worry about Gaza later. (cont.)

8 ) Yehuda Solomon / Israel
05/07/2012 00:36
@ Emile/Palestine, You're probably right for believing the Palestinians' families and friends in the PA have vested, financial interests in maintaining the status quo and for disbanding the PA but I again say to you and everyone you can do all the (peaceful or not) civil disobedience in the world against the PA or us. The honest truth is Israel will never absorb the W. Bank and Gaza Palestinians as equal citizens of a 1-nation solution, absolutely NEVER. So ... if no fight ... then (cont.)

9 ) Yehuda Solomon / Israel
05/07/2012 00:50
negotiate ??? ... Nasser Latham: Your frustration is beyond crystal-clear: It's as true and piercing as the sun. As 1 of the most knowledgeable and respected Editors-in-Chief of 1 of the most highly regarded--and no, I'm not patronizing you--Mideast news organizations do you really expect sending the PA to negotiate will do any better ??? ... After everything you've seen with your own eyes ??? Tell me, please, when you try something indefinitely without achievement, what is that called ???

10 ) Joe Fattal / USA
05/07/2012 02:20
Not doing anything for the Palestinians is putting Israel on the defensive, doing something negotiate or launch few rockets is putting Israel on the offensive, and Israel rather be on the offensive. So Mr. Laham statement is correct "No peace but no war". If the Palestinians send a hardliner to negotiate, Israel has one of their own, Netanyahu, so nothing will be accomplished. If the Palestinians send a moderate, the Palestinians wont get nothing back. Let the mountain come to Muhammad.

11 ) some one / some wyhere
05/07/2012 05:39
MR.Nasser
your article is to the point for 40 years your writing elegant and your idea clear now they have to choose fight or negotiate which is absolute one way or other but fight is not going to do you any good 2 intifada did not worke suicide bombing get you wall gaza evacuation divied you not all their to blame best is SIT AND TALK AND DO NOT PROMISE IMPOSIBLE
with all due respect

12 ) Big / Baby
05/07/2012 05:40
Abbas: "Get me what I want, or I won't even talk to Israel," and someone should tell him that IT IS TIME TO GROW UP, to Negotiate, Compromise, and Yes, Even Surrender to Israeli terms, FOR THE WELFARE OF YOUR PEOPLE & THEIR FUTURE STATE.

13 ) @ Giacomo-3 / USA too
05/07/2012 05:45
You are totally right, but you should emphize the last part more: "The only action that will further the Palestinian statehood dreams is a unified Palestinian government, THAT NEGOTIATES WITH ISRAEL".

14 ) @ tora-5 / USA
05/07/2012 05:57
1- Don't be disappointed at the cancellation, since the Abbas-Mofaz meeting could be rescheduled in Jerusalem, if the PA leaders are ready, 2- IF the Palestinian leaders are ready for peace, the people will follow, if he goes to Jerusalem for peace, like Sadat, and 3- then some Palestinians (Hamas, PRC, PFLP, etc.) will likely murder Abbas, much like Egyptians later murdered Sadat, but still that peace endures !!

15 ) Too Much / Love
05/07/2012 06:02
Comments 6-9, by "Yehuda Solomon" were probably writen by Nasser Latham of Maan.

16 ) Selina Owen / Papua New Guinea
05/07/2012 06:05
1. Consider Palestine becoming part of Syria again because thats where they originate.
2. Israel was taken out of the Palestine landmass to become what it is today.
So what is left from that remains as Palestine.
3. Historical and biblical records evidenced that the land was given to the line of David who are the Jewish today.

17 ) palestine / palestine
05/07/2012 19:03
this is impotent and handy caped leadership you will not expect any good out come. very sad

18 ) Nour / One State
05/07/2012 20:52
Lahham is out of his mind. Negotiate?? With Benjamin Millikowky? How about trashing the two states fallacy and finally accepting that Palestinw is indivisible? The obvious third option is BDS and total civil disobediance starting with derecognizing the PA and admitting it has failed to deliver independence.

19 ) Nour / One State
05/07/2012 20:55
#6 How about you set up shop in Uganda or Australia as originally envisaged? your wet dream.of Palestinians packing and heading to arab countries is just that a silly dream. We would rather face death than wilkingly give you Nakba 2.0

20 ) @ Nour (18 & 19) / \ Tibi/Tubas
06/07/2012 16:59
If the PA government is "derecognized", or ends it's relations with Israel, or supports harming Israel with disobediance or another Intifada:
1- there would be Neither a reason for Israel to allow travel,
either into Israel or Israeli controlled Area C, from Areas A/B,
2- Nor to Cooperate with UNRWA aid deliveries or other importations,
3- Nor to continue supplying Areas A/B with any water or electricity,
until the PA government recreates a Non-Hostile relationship with Israel !!!

21 ) peshawar / Indonesia
06/07/2012 19:50
i saw very fine news of high living sandards within this society, and just last week many new classrooms were outlined for educational improvements, if we can only get past the scarce water resources, then maybe there is a chance. i talked once to a person about religion, and we concluded God is for human rights for all humans, the Israelis sometimes doesn't believe this maybe, and some other countries don't either.

22 ) johnny benson / usa
06/07/2012 20:55
lets look at the options....fight....useless and stupid....suicide....negotiations....maybe,but even if you could get the old deals....you would have to turn them down as was done twice before....because?...we all know why....nothing but israels demise is really accetable .....so what to do ?...sit back and steal the billions of aid ..as arafat did...and be happy with that

23 ) Joey / USA
06/07/2012 21:10
Maybe it's about time Palestine becomes recognized as an Observer State in the UN by going to the General Assembly. Once that is done, Palestine can turn the table on Israel and fight a strong legal battle for independence. It will be tough and the Palestinian people have to be ready, but making the State of Palestine a legal reality is Palestine's strongest card. The second strongest is UNITY. without UNITY, all Palestinians are doomed. It's time independents started taking control!!!

24 ) southparkbear / usa
08/07/2012 00:36
Abbas really really wants to Figotiate

25 ) Doreen Said / USA- Palestine
08/07/2012 17:01
I agree 100%; unfortunately if you give in to negotiations, and abandon the boycotts, you are labeled as someone that supports normalization and a traitor. I am sick of my people being completely helpless, and I am sick of being afraid to say what needs to be said. The conflict must end, and excluding ourselves from any form of conversation, not contributing to the forwarding of the conflict, and showing complete indifference to the status quo does not helps us at all. All we want is peace!

26 ) Table / Chair
09/07/2012 21:25
Joey #23 - palestinians can not turn the table - they do not have one. They do not have nothing. And they will forever have nothing as long as they have leaders like Yasser Arafat and Mahmud Abbas.

27 ) Emile / Palestine
10/07/2012 00:16
It is a shame that the likes of Yehuda Solomon, a total racist and fascist, is allowed to post here. He is absolutely no different from the Nazis. He openly advocates transfer of the entire Palestinian population. Mr. Lahham, Noor is absolutely right in saying that you are out of your mind. Just look at all the praise your are getting from the Zionist fascists who post here.

28 ) Yehuda Solomon / Israel
13/07/2012 18:32
@ 27) Emile/Palestine, NO ... It is NOT a shame ... It's HIGHLY COMMENDABLE of MNA to allow freedom of expression no matter how strong, serious or sensitive it MAY BE. Only by allowing honest TRUTH about how one feels can TRUE understanding be known. I fully SUPPORT your expression, no matter how strongly I disagree with it. Don't label me a Nazi, Fascist, racist, "ethnic cleanser," land thief or other crap. The Nazis committed genocide against us; I sure as hell would NEVER even (cont.)

29 ) Yehuda Solomon / Israel
13/07/2012 18:33
THINK about doing that to Palestinians. Yes, I openly and vehemently advocate TRANSFER of all Palestinians (west of the Jordan River) TO Jordan/Palestine. THAT'S their NATION [which is approx. 75% of all TOTAL (Ottoman Empire) Palestine]. I want ALL Palestinians to have the best of peace, happiness and prosperity anywhere but NOT in Israel. So you and Nour (@ 19) FORGET about all this Uganda/Australia, Nakba 2.0 CRAP ALREADY. Nasser Laham has said his TRUE thoughts; his agenda is only THAT.

30 ) Emile / Palestine
14/07/2012 13:26
Yehuda says:"FORGET about all this Uganda/Australia, Nakba 2.0 CRAP ALREADY" Just replace the word Nakba with Holocaust and you have the words of a neo Nazi. If it looks like a fascist, smells like a fascist and talks like a fascist...its probably a fascist.

31 ) Emile / USA
14/07/2012 13:28
28) Yes, and the Jerusalem post should print all comments of Neo Nazis....freedom of speech Yehuda boy, right? You disgust me.
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Analysis: Salam Fayyad doomed by Israeli and Palestinian enemies alike
Saeb Erekat: 65 years of impunity
Israel army doubts third intifada but on alert

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013