اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter

Advanced

Palestine envoy: Jewish refugee meeting at UN aims for confusion
Published Sunday 23/09/2012 (updated) 24/09/2012 15:11
BETHLEHEM (Ma'an) -- Palestine's UN envoy said on Sunday that while Israel had the right to hold a panel discussion at the United Nations asserting the claims of Jews who fled Arab countries after 1948, the only purpose of the meeting is to distract attention from Palestinian refugees.

Riyad Mansour told Ma'an that all Arab countries with the exception of Egypt boycotted the meeting at the UN headquarters in New York on Friday. Arab envoys at the UN lodged unsuccessful protests to call it off.

"The Israeli ambassador has the same right as any other member to hold a meeting at the UN," Masour said.

But he accused the conference of aiming to cause confusion and pull attention away from Palestinian refugees.

On Saturday Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri said: "Those Jews are criminals rather than refugees. They are the ones who turned the Palestinian people into refugees, and for that reason, the Hamas movement views this conference as a dangerous, unprecedented move which contributes to the falsification of history and reversing of facts."

But Israeli leaders considered it a victory for a population that is increasingly being linked to the peace process with the Palestinians.

"Between the walls of the UN we are starting to bring justice to the Jewish refugees who were tortured, persecuted and driven away, and whose rights were revoked," said Danny Ayalon, Israel's deputy foreign minister, according to Israeli media.

"We are 64 years late, but it's never too late to bring justice and discuss the historic facts."

Hundreds of thousands of Middle Eastern Jews left predominantly Arab countries amid growing hostility following the establishment of Israel in the late 1940s.

Israel had also drafted a "Law of Return" that granted instant citizenship to anyone who can claim Jewish lineage. Most immigrants had no modern ties to the land.

At the same time, over 700,000 Palestinians were driven from or fled historic Palestine and today make up the largest refugee population on earth.

Israeli media reported a week earlier that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was preparing to add compensations for Jews who came from Arab and Muslim countries as a condition for any future peace deal.

PLO negotiator Saeb Erekat said in response that there was no connection between Palestinian refugees and Israelis whose families are from Arab countries, but he supported their right of return.

"We are not against any Jew who wants to return to Morocco, Iraq, Libya, Egypt and elsewhere. I believe no Arab state rejects the Jewish right of returning to their native lands," he said.
Print Send to friend
1 ) Mariam / Spain
23/09/2012 16:50
Let each refugee go to their land. That would be just the perfect solution! All Israelis that came form somewhere else and his descendent should go back there and Palestinian refugees around the world will return to the land. Win- Win situation for everyone!

2 ) Sam / UK
23/09/2012 23:43
There's a huge difference Mariam. These Jews were ethnically cleansed from the lands they lived in for - in some cases - thousands of years. Until then they had been loyal citizens of those countries that they dwelt in. The Palestinians who fled sided with the aggressors - the Arab countries surrounding Israel who attacked it in violation of the UN resolution - and lost. Since when do losers get back land that they lost in a war of aggression?

3 ) Business / Israel
24/09/2012 03:02
Let Mariam return to Arabia and all the Palestinians also. All the Jews will continue to Israel! Win Win Win! Spain is Spanish again, Israel is Jewish and all the Arab Muslims can be back in Arabia. We like it. Anyway, regardless of Spain or Arabia, the Jews are coming back to Israel and no one can stop it. Soon most of the world's Jews will live in Israel - it just gets better and better.

4 ) @ Mariam-1 / USA
24/09/2012 03:07
In a "perfect" world, that could work, but in a REAL WORLD, that will NOT, and you need to try a REAL SOLUTION, like since an equal number of Jews and Arabs were displaced, - Let the Arab refugees go to an Arab land, that expelled Jews, AND - Let the Jewish refugees go to a Jewish land," that expelled Arabs, OR - Let each refugee accept fair compensation for what ancestors lost !!!

5 ) gabi / australia
24/09/2012 03:23
It is just nonsense to try and connect the Palestinian refugee issue with Jewish refugees. The Palestinians were not responsible for Jewish refugees, while Israel was wholly responsible for the Palestinian refugees. And how can Netanyahu call for compensation for the Jewish refugees when he repeatedly says no right of return for Palestinians, and no compensation either, despite the fact that Israel was granted entry to the UN in May 1949 by Res. 271, providing it abided by Res. 181, and 194.

6 ) Lilith / The World
24/09/2012 07:04
What fantastic idea Miriam. Israelis are where they came from. That's why they are called Israelis. If you are referring to Palestinian Arabs that were born in Israel prior to 1948, there wouldn't be too many of them around now. The youngest would be 64.

7 ) southparkbear / usa
24/09/2012 08:05
exactly #1, Jews were deported from their land of Israel, prosecuted around the world and managed to come back to their homeland Israel

8 ) Dweikat / Palestine
24/09/2012 11:27
Being a Jew is following the jewish religion for those who did not know that... You can have a German jew..American Jew.. Palestinian Jew etc.. And if someone convert to the Jewish religion that don't make him an owner of Palestine...the same way when a French person converts to Islam he will stay a Frenchman but with Islam as his religion... Palestine is for the muslim/christian/jewish Palestinians not for germans/russian/american/dutch/french people who follows the jewish religion

9 ) ian / australia
24/09/2012 12:16
"...he accused the conference of aiming to cause confusion" Well, he got that right. This is not hard. It's all in the UDHR (and Covenants) and has, as they say, the force of law. People driven from their homes have the right to return. It doesn't mean they're compelled to return, or will be forcibly returned against their wishes, just that if they want to, they have the inalienable right to do so. And it applies to everyone...including Jews and Palestinians. So Jews have a right to return to

10 ) ian / australia
24/09/2012 12:17
(contd.) Arab countries they fled (which obviously most don't want to do) and Palestinians have the right to return to what is now Israel. The only hard thing to grasp is the gall of Danny Ayalon's interpretation that it only applies for Jews.

11 ) Rami / Palestine
24/09/2012 14:50
#7 except that their homeland wasn't their homeland. The misconception here is that nationality = religion when it clearly doesn't and never did. Russian Jews are Russian by nationality and Jewish by faith. German Jews are German by nationality and Jewish by faith. What connection do these people have with historic Palestine? None. By your argument a Muslim in Iran or a Christian in Italy can here and claim that this is his homeland too. After all, its the birthplace of 3 religions right?

12 ) Mark / USA
24/09/2012 14:55
And since Israel was stupid enough to open this topic, I'm sure that they have now recognized the right of return for all Palestinian refugees as well as their rights to reparations and will surely compensate ALL PALESTINIANS for their losses, right?
Name Country
Comment
Characters
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.

Share/Bookmark

Mursi orders military operation to free hostages
Man killed in Gaza tunnel collapse
Palestinian killed, 2 hurt in Lebanon clash

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2013